Modulate
‍
vs. ElevenLabs

A head-to-head comparison of Modulate Transcribe and ElevenLabs Scribe v2 for speech to text, real-time transcription and voice AI applications.

See Modulate in Action
Futuristic black cube device emitting glowing blue and purple light waves and digital chat icons on a dark background.

Why Teams Choose Modulate Over ElevenLabs

Conversation Intelligence vs. Voice Generation

Modulate and ElevenLabs built their respective products with different goals in mind. ElevenLabs is a voice generation and agent platform, providing text to speech, voice cloning, dubbing, music generation and conversational agents. The main use case for ElevenLabs’ speech to text model is to power captions, dubbing pipelines and agent ingestion. Modulate is a voice intelligence platform built around understanding live conversations.

Speech to Text Built for Real Conversations

Modulate’s Multilingual model regularly ranks near the top of Hugging Face’s Open ASR Leaderboard and outperforms ElevenLabs Scribe v2 on 7 of the leaderboard’s 10 benchmarks. Modulate achieves this level of accuracy by training on more than 500 million hours of real-world conversational audio, not just studio-quality samples. That means it can deal with interruptions, people talking over each other and background noise.

ElevenLabs Scribe v2 currently performs well on clean, studio-recorded audio, but it isn’t designed around the less controlled conditions of everyday calls. Modulate Transcribe is optimized for contact-center-style conversations, where messy audio is the norm.

Lower Cost at Scale

Modulate Transcribe costs $0.03/hour for batch transcription and $0.06/hour for real-time streaming. ElevenLabs Scribe v2 costs roughly $0.22/hour for batch transcription and $0.39/hour for streaming. That means Modulate is about one-seventh the cost of ElevenLabs for batch transcription and about one-sixth the cost for streaming. These costs can add up quickly for contact centers and platforms transcribing millions of minutes of audio per month.

Modulate Transcribe is Modulate’s speech to text engine. Building on Modulate Transcribe’s speech transcription, Velma, Modulate’s Ensemble Listening Model (ELM), employs machine learning to detect fraud, intent, sentiment and policy violations as they occur. Velma is a layer of intelligence on top of transcription, and is not included in this page’s pricing comparison. We are comparing pricing for speech to text only.

Pay for Only the Signals You Need

With Modulate Transcribe, you get speaker diarization at no added cost. Emotion detection ($0.02/hour), accent detection ($0.01/hour) and PII/PHI tagging ($0.02/hour) are optional, so you only pay for them when you need those capabilities. All three together for multilingual batch transcription is $0.08/hour. Compare that to the approximately $0.22/hour ElevenLabs charges for just batch transcription using Scribe v2, and that’s before you add on its 30% premium for entity detection.

Transcription Benchmark (Accuracy vs. Price)
Average Word Error Rate (WER) across Earnings-22 and VoxPopuli datasets
Lowest WER, lowest cost
Cost per 1000 minutes of audio
Avg. Word Error Rate
modulate-velma-2
scribe-v2
gemini-2.5-pro
universal
speechmatics-enhanced
solaria-1
gpt-4o-transcribe
chirp-2
speechmatics-standard
whisper-large-v3
nova-3
8
9
10
11
12 %
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
$9
0

Understanding the Models: What We're Actually Comparing

This page compares Modulate’s speech to text model (Modulate Transcribe) to ElevenLabs’ speech to text model (Scribe v2). Below is an overview of where each product sits within its company’s ecosystem:

  1. Modulate Transcribe: Built on a foundation of over 500 million hours of real-world conversational audio, this model is engineered for contact center audio and is capable of handling frequent speech overlaps, background noise and interruptions. This is the model being used for all pricing and performance comparisons on this page.
  2. Item C

Text link

Bold text

Emphasis

Superscript

Subscript

Modulate vs. Resemble AI:
The Breakdown

Features
Modulate
Resemble AI
Core Focus
Helps businesses understand conversations, sentiment, safety, and intent in voice interactions using machine learning.
AI voice generation platform that also offers deepfake detection and synthetic media authentication tools.
Primary Technology
Velma is a voice-native AI powered by an Ensemble Listening Module (ELM).
Neural speech synthesis models for voice cloning and generative voice AI.
Benchmark Transparency
Listed on various public leaderboards and synthetic voice detection benchmarks.
2x the error rate compared to Modulate.
Supported Use Cases
Contact centers, AI agents, fraud detection, voice moderation, and CS analytics.
Voice cloning, AI narration, voice assistants, and synthetic media detection.
Pricing
Modulate offers predictable pricing based on usage (per minute) via an API or via enterprise plans.
Pricing varies by voice generation usage and enterprise deepfake detection tools.
Free Trial/Credits/Demo
Modulate provides users with free API credits to build on and a platform preview, as well as demos and sales consultations.
Offers demos and developer access depending on product usage.
Synthetic Voice Detection
Yes, Modulate detects AI-generated voices in real-world conversations.
Yes, Resemble AI detects AI-generated audio through signal artifact analysis.
Voice Authentication
Modulate can verify a caller’s voice as part of its fraud detection use cases.
Not a primary capability.
Fraud Detection
Yes, Modulate can detect scams, social engineering attacks, and suspicious conversations in real-time.
Not designed specifically for fraud detection workflows.
Audio Analysis Methods
Voice-native analysis detecting tone, emotion, pacing, hesitation, and conversational cues.
Signal analysis to detect artifacts from generative audio models.
Conversation Understanding
Modulate’s AI engine is trained to understand the meaning of conversations, tone and intent of speakers.
Not designed to analyze conversational behavior.
Voice Context Analysis
Deep understanding of speaker behavior including emotional signals and other conversation specific nuances.
Focuses primarily on authenticity detection rather than conversation context.
Deepfake Detection Method
Multi-model voice analysis evaluating acoustic signals and conversational behavior.
Machine learning models detect artifacts associated with AI-generated speech.
Real-time Voice Monitoring
Real-time alerts and action triggers when Modulate detects things like fraud, frustration, safety concerns, agent coaching opportunities, and more.
Supports detection APIs but primarily focused on analyzing media authenticity rather than monitoring live conversations.
AI Architecture
Designed with a proprietary ELM specifically for building voice-native AI solutions.
Neural speech synthesis and media detection models.
Voice Generation
Not a primary feature.
Generates synthetic voices and cloned speech.
Automation Capabilities
Velma’s API enables automated alerts, workflows, escalations, and intelligence triggers.
APIs support voice generation workflows and synthetic media analysis.
Deployment Environments
Software-as-a-service platform with a robust API. Integrates into existing voice stacks, CCaaS platforms, and telephony systems.
Cloud-based APIs for voice generation and deepfake detection.
Integration Approach
API-first approach for developers and teams looking to integrate with voice hardware and software.
API-driven platform for voice generation and media detection services.
Data Encryption
Enterprise-grade encryption for voice data and transcripts during processing and storage.
Enterprise security protections for generated and analyzed media.
Security & Access Controls
Enterprise-grade, ISO 27001-aligned controls, monitoring, and governance.
Enterprise-grade security and authentication controls.

Here’s What This
Means for You

Visibility into every conversation, not just synthetic audio.

You don’t just want to know if someone used synthetic audio on a call. You want to know what happened. Layer those insights on top of detection. Modulate offers tone, intent, and behavior analytics in real time, rather than a binary “yes or no” to whether something was AI generated. 

Go beyond deepfake detection to identify fraud.

Tools like Resemble AI are great at identifying synthetic voices, but that’s just a single threat vector. Some real-world attacks today are perpetrated with regular human voices using social engineering. Modulate detects those behaviors and patterns in real time, from urgency to manipulation to cognitive errors. 

Real-time detection and intelligence to act on during an active call.

Modulate was built specifically for use cases within live voice applications. That means risks, alerts, and coaching opportunities are surfaced as they happen during a call. If you’ll be using this technology on active customer interactions or within contact centers, that’s key.

Technology built for operations use cases.

Resemble AI specializes in synthetic media processing and voice generation. Modulate helps you operate real-world conversations at scale. Contact center monitoring, fraud prevention, compliance, and AI agent coaching are just a few of the use cases for Modulate.

Modulate makes our benchmark results on public datasets available to everyone.

This means you can look at how our model performs compared to the industry on standardized datasets. This is great if you need to provide proof to stakeholders on tooling decisions, or require accuracy percentages for regulated industries.

Deploy quickly without reworking your voice stack.

Both Modulate and Resemble AI offer APIs, but Modulate works out of the box with voice and telephony solutions. You can analyze calls, trigger actions, and scale up usage without changing your existing tech stack. 

You don’t have to choose between detection and intelligence.

Both Modulate and Resemble AI can detect AI-generated audio. Where Modulate differs is after that detection occurs. Modulate provides teams with continuous intelligence about fraud, CX, and operations, while Resemble AI focuses on voice generation and authentication.

Build Voice Systems That Understand Conversations

Voice contains far more intelligence than authenticity signals. Voice also conveys intent, risk, and opportunities to take action in real time. Platforms that only deliver synthetic audio detection can tell you whether a voice is real, but not what’s really going on in a conversation. 

Modulate turns voice data into actionable intelligence. Our deepfake detection and conversation analysis technology arm teams with the ability to monitor calls for fraud, compliance, and sentiment as they’re happening, not after the call concludes. Get real-time responses, make smarter decisions, and gain visibility across every customer interaction. 

Illustration of an audio transcription process showing audio input connected to an API that processes sound waves into binary code which produces a transcript output on a screen.

Features Built for Real-World Voice Interactions

Live voice interactions are noisy and unpredictable. Calls have background noise, interruptions, people talking over each other, and changing context. Voice intelligence needs to operate within that chaos to deliver real-time insights. 

Monitor Conversations in Real Time

Make sense of live calls as they’re happening. Identify fraud risks, compliance violations and customer sentiment during the call and take action now rather than after.

Deepfake Detection with Context

Detect AI voices in seconds but also analyze how that synthetic voice interacts during the call. Distinguish between false positives and true fraud by understanding the conversation around the AI voice.

Detect Fraud at the Conversation Level

Pinpoint social engineering and other manipulative tactics by understanding tone, pace, pauses and inconsistencies. Detect threats that use more than just fake audio.

Detect Intent as Well as Speech Artifacts

Go beyond deepfake detection by understanding not just what was said, but how it was said and how it will impact the interaction.

Trigger Workflow Actions

Use real-time alerts and insights to trigger action directly from a call. Set up alerts, escalations or workflows based on live call analysis.

Seamless Speech Intelligence Integration

Integrate transcription, conversation intelligence and fraud detection into your existing workflows quickly and easily. No need to make complex telecom changes or enroll speakers.

Enterprise Capabilities and Flexible Deployment

All of our products come with robust security, encryption, and governance features. Transcribe and analyze as many calls as you need without losing performance.

Digital sound waves flowing into a cube, which processes them into multiple chat message bubbles with speech icons and checkmarks.

What You Gain with Modulate

Faster identification of synthetic and suspicious callers. While our deepfake detection models will find AI voices in seconds, Modulate also scores conversational behavior so you can triage and take action sooner.

Gain visibility into every conversation. Other tools require you to submit clips or suspected deepfake audio. Modulate analyzes your entire conversations so you can discover fraud, compliance, and CX risks at scale.

Protect against more than synthetic voices. Voice generation and authenticity products can identify AI-generated audio. Modulate’s analysis of tone, intent and conversational dynamics shows you what’s really going on during the call.

Detect caller risk signals for real-world social engineering. Fraud isn’t always synthetic audio. Real world risk can come from urgency, manipulation, inconsistency and more. Modulate helps you detect those signals so your agents can recognize dangerous calls that otherwise look normal.

Maintain high accuracy on low-quality call audio. Calls come with background noise, interruptions, connectivity drops, and more. Since Modulate is trained with real-world conversational audio, low-quality audio doesn’t impact accuracy.

Simple pricing as you scale. Usage-based pricing means you can analyze large volumes of calls without unexpected costs or difficult implementation. 

Deepfake Detection + Voice Intelligence You Can Trust

Identifying synthetic voices is only part of the battle. Security, sales, and CX teams need visibility into every conversation: fraud cues, customer intent, operational risk. Context matters.

That’s where Modulate’s deepfake detection and conversation intelligence solutions come together. Built on one platform designed for real-world voice interactions, you can monitor calls live as they’re happening, identify social engineering and malicious behavior, and easily surface high-risk conversations with API integrations that fit into your workflows.

Try Modulate Free
Stylized chat message timeline with timestamps and checkmark icons on a light background.